Why Not Be as Precise as Possible?
By Joe Ferry on Sep 30, 2008 in Featured | comments(0)
I normally agree with Seth Godin’s brilliant observations on marketing and what makes people do the things they do.
But I think he missed the mark with his latest musing on the importance of being precise. Seth argues against “senseless precision” and says he “wants precision where it matters…but only there.”
the most obvious question is this: who decides where precision matters?” Is it the reader or the writer?
I guess it’s my reporter upbringing but I’ve always been taught to be as precise as possible. Saying the getaway car was “dark” was never good enough for most copy editors I worked with. Was it dark green or blue or black? they wanted to know. And if you said it was dark blue, they would ask if it was royal blue or midnight blue.
Why say “about 100″ if you know it was 105 or 98? Why say it was “about 3 o’clock” if you know it was 3:05 or 2:56? Everything has a proper name – Sputnik is not the same as Sputnik I. If you know it, use it.
To me, being precise adds a layer of reality and credibility to writing. Using a generality when you have a specific at your disposal is lazy and, well, imprecise.
Seth is right one one point — as my copy editors pointed out — dark is not a color.
Popularity: 18% [?]

